The Austrian Actor

WHERE AUSTRIAN ECONOMICS MEETS REAL WORLD ACTION

ISSUE #28

STANDARD EDITION

From January, Vietnam's minimum wage rises 7.3% to 9.2%, fastest in its poorest region. The price of work is set by a council and a map, not by the people who do it.

You run a small sewing workshop in a commune in Cao Bằng, in Vietnam's far north. You have twelve workers on simple jobs. From 1 January the law says you must pay each of them at least VND 4.04 million a month, up from 3.7 million. That is a rise of 9.2%, the biggest in the country.

Drive into one of the three city wards the decree puts in Region III and the legal floor is VND 4.45 million. In central Hanoi it is 5.7 million. Same work, same sewing machine. The price changes at a line on a map.

Nothing about your orders changed on 2 November, when the decree was signed. Only the law did.

POLICY SPOTLIGHT

Decree 399/2026/ND-CP, signed on 2 November, sets new minimum wages for every worker under a labour contract from 1 January 2027. The country is split into four regions, and every commune and ward in its 34 provinces and cities is assigned to one of them.

Vietnam's minimum wage from 1 January 2027

Region

Monthly floor (VND)

Rise

I

5,700,000

7.3%

II

5,080,000

7.4%

III

4,450,000

7.5%

IV

4,040,000

9.2%

There are hourly floors too, from VND 27,400 in Region I to 19,400 in Region IV. Each branch pays the floor of the area it sits in. An industrial zone that straddles two areas pays the higher. Pay by the day, by the week or by the piece must still work out at the floor or above, and premiums already agreed, such as at least 7% above the floor for trained jobs, cannot be cut.

The number came from the National Wage Council, a 17-member body chaired by a deputy minister, with members from the Ministry of Home Affairs, the Vietnam General Confederation of Labour, employers' organisations and two independent experts. The union confederation asked for 9.8% or 8.5%. The chamber of commerce offered about 5%, preferably from July 2027. On 16 July, after a second round of negotiations, the Council reached a “consensus” on 7.8% on average.

The Government's case: the rise “aims to ensure a minimum standard of living for workers while maintaining a balanced approach to the interests of both employees and employers.”

Concede what is fair. The rises are modest, a few hundred thousand dong a month. They were negotiated, with both sides at the table. Average pay is already well above the floor, at VND 9.2 million a month in the third quarter. And the economy is growing fast: 8.18% in the first half of 2026.

Take every word of that as true. What follows is unaffected.

THE AUSTRIAN LENS

Agreed, but not by the people who pay it

Every wage that is actually paid is agreed. An employer offers what the work is worth to them. A worker takes it, or turns it down and finds something better. That is the only agreement that counts, because the two people making it are the ones who live with it.

The 7.8% was agreed too, but by proxies. A union confederation opened high, a chamber of commerce opened low, and a council chaired by the state settled between them. Nobody from your workshop in Cao Bằng was in the room. Neither was the person you would hire next. Their price is now set by people who will neither pay it nor be paid it.

A map is not a market

The map gives the game away. By drawing four regions, the state admits that the price of labour is not the same everywhere. What a worker's time is worth depends on what it can produce and on who wants it, and that differs from one town to the next.

Then it replaces the millions of prices a market would find with four, drawn ward by ward in Hanoi. The line has nothing to do with the work. A factory that straddles it pays the higher rate. A commune that is merged or renamed keeps its old rate “until the Government issues a new rule”. The geography is arbitrary. Supply and demand are not.

Low pay is a signal, not the disease

Wages are lower in Region IV because output per worker is lower: less capital, fewer machines, further from the big markets. The poverty is an outcome. It tells you where capital has not yet gone.

And the lower wage is the region's one advantage in attracting it. It is the reason a factory might set up in Cao Bằng instead of next to Hanoi. That is how pay rises for real: more capital, more output per worker, more employers competing for the same people.

This decree does the opposite. It raises the floor fastest exactly where workers produce least. In 2016 Region IV's floor was 69% of Region I's. From January it is 71%. The gap that tells capital where to go is being closed by decree.

What you see, and what you don't

What you see is the raise for the worker who keeps the job. What you don't see is the twelfth worker not hired, the hours cut, the order that goes to a workshop over the border, the machine bought a year sooner.

And there is a group the decree does not even reach. It covers workers “under labour contracts”. Six in ten Vietnamese workers are in informal jobs: 60.6% in the third quarter, and 41.9% even in industry and construction. For them the floor is not a protection. It is the price of the ticket into a formal job, and it has just gone up again.

The record

If the right price of labour could be set from the capital, the floor would have found a level and stayed there. Here is what it did instead.

Vietnam's minimum wage, set by decree, Region I and Region IV, 2016–2027.

Vietnam's minimum wage, set by decree, Region I and Region IV, 2016–2027.

It has never come down. Since 2020 it has been held for long stretches, 30 months, then 24, then 18, and each time it moved, it moved up. Between 2016 and 2027 Region I's floor rose 63%, and Region IV's rose 68%.

“Without a floor, employers would pay whatever they like”

That's the best objection. But look at the pay that is not set by decree. Average income is VND 9.2 million a month, and wage workers average 10.1 million. That is far above even Region I's floor. Most workers are paid well above the floor, because other employers would offer them more.

A worker's protection is not a number in a decree. It is the next employer down the road, and the freedom to walk out and take a better offer. A floor does nothing for the worker an employer can't afford at that price, except keep them out.

The floor protects the job you have, and taxes the one you'd get next

A minimum wage looks like a gift to the lowest paid. In practice, it is a ban on any job worth less than the floor to the person paying for it. In Vietnam the ban is drawn on a map, and it tightens fastest where jobs are scarcest.

REAL-WORLD BUSINESS IMPACT

❝

If you employ staff in Vietnam on simple jobs

—       Check each site's region commune by commune, not by province. The decree's appendix assigns every ward and commune. Budget for 7.3% to 9.2% more from 1 January.

❝

If you have sites in more than one region

—       Each unit pays its own area's floor. An industrial zone that spans areas pays the highest of them, so a site on a boundary can cost more than its neighbours.

❝

If you pay by the day or by the piece

—       Convert it. Daily, weekly and piece-rate pay must work out at the monthly or hourly floor or above. Premiums already agreed above the floor cannot be cut.

❝

If you are choosing where to put a plant

—       The cost gap between regions is narrowing by law. Region IV's floor is now 71% of Region I's, up from 69% in 2016. Price the decision on output per worker, not on the floor alone.

YOUR ACTIONABLE TAKEAWAY

This is analysis, not legal or financial advice. Check your own position with an adviser.

❝

01 · Find your region, ward by ward, in the decree's appendix, for every site.

❝

02 · Recalculate every pay form (daily, weekly, piece rate) against the new floor before 1 January.

❝

03 · Review contracts, collective agreements and pay rules now. The decree requires it, and bars cutting overtime, night-work and existing premiums.

❝

04 · Expect the next round. This year's council deal came in July. Whenever the floor has moved, it has moved up.

❝

05 · Plan on productivity, not on the floor. What a job is worth is what the work produces. The decree only sets the price below which that job is illegal.

THE FREE-MARKET ALTERNATIVE

Let workers and employers agree pay between themselves, under one law for everyone, with no statutory floor and no wage map drawn by the government.

That protects the worker in Cao Bằng who would take a job at the wage an employer can offer, and the employer who would offer it.

It restores a price that tells both of them, and every investor deciding where to build, what the work is worth.

OVER TO YOU
If you employ people in Vietnam, or anywhere with a regional minimum wage, has the line on the map ever changed where you hired? Reply and tell me.

Stay free,

Jean-Pierre

The Austrian Actor

P.S. New here? Every past issue is in the archive at theaustrianactor.com.

Before you go: if this made a policy clearer, forward it to one person it affects. When they subscribe with your link, you get our Policy Impact Checklist, and five referrals earn you a short private explanation of any policy you choose.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate