The Austrian Actor

WHERE AUSTRIAN ECONOMICS MEETS REAL WORLD ACTION

ISSUE #26

FLAGSHIP EDITION

From April 2027 the first £3,000 of side income is tax-free. But frozen allowances, tapers and childcare cliffs still punish the next pound you earn.

You live in the South East and work in London. You and your partner both work, and you have a toddler in nursery. Your salary sits a little under £100,000, which sounds like a lot until you see the rent, the train fare and the nursery bill.

This year your employer offers you a bonus, in cash. You do the sum. Above £100,000, the state starts taking back your tax-free personal allowance, so each extra pound costs you 62p in tax and National Insurance. And once your adjusted net income passes £100,000, your family loses eligibility for the working-parent funded nursery hours and the Government’s top-up on childcare. Take the cash, and you could end the year poorer.

So you do what the rules reward. You put the bonus into your pension, where you can’t touch it for decades.

You’d had an idea for a weekend business, too. From April 2027, the first £3,000 of side income will be tax-free. After that, every pound lands on top of your salary, at 62p, or worse.

You let the idea go. Nobody records that decision.

POLICY SPOTLIGHT

In Budget 2026 the Government announced that the trading allowance will triple, from £1,000 to £3,000, from 6 April 2027. If your gross takings from trading on the side stay within it, your profit is treated as nil: no tax, no need to work out a profit, and, from 2027, no need to report it.

HMRC’s own estimates:

—       around 400,000 people will pay about £380 less a year;

—       about 100,000 will no longer need to report their side income;

—       up to 1.4 million could benefit, through lower tax or less paperwork;

—       paperwork savings of £15.7 million a year, at a cost of £225 million in 2028-29.

It also delivers early on a promise the Government made in spring 2025, to raise the reporting threshold for side income by the end of this Parliament.

Concede all of it. It is a real tax cut and a real simplification, and it is the right direction. The Finance Bill introduced on 4 November carries it, in clause 23, and Parliament can still amend it.

Take every word of that as true. What follows is unaffected.

Because the allowance sits on top of everything else in the system:

The lines the £3,000 sits on

Line

What happens

Moved since

£12,570

Tax-free personal allowance

Frozen from 2021 to 2031

£50,270

Higher-rate tax starts

Frozen from 2021 to 2031

£60,000 to £80,000

Child Benefit clawed back

Set in 2024

£100,000

Personal allowance withdrawn; childcare support lost

Never, since 2010

£125,140

Personal allowance gone

Frozen with the allowance

THE AUSTRIAN LENS

The next pound

Economic decisions are made at the margin. Nobody decides whether to work at all. They decide whether to take the extra shift, the bonus, the client on Saturday. So the tax that matters is the tax on the next pound.

Here is what the state takes from it.

What the state takes from the next pound you earn. Employee in England, 2026-27.

What the state takes from the next pound you earn. Employee in England, 2026-27.

The rate on the next pound rises from 28% to 42%, then jumps to 62% between £100,000 and £125,140, then falls back to 47%. A parent of two pays about 54p on the next pound between £60,000 and £80,000, as Child Benefit is clawed back. And at the bottom, a worker on Universal Credit earning above their work allowance keeps only about 32p of each extra pound once tax, National Insurance and the 55% withdrawal of benefit are counted.

This is not a progressive system. A progressive system would rise steadily with income. This one punishes the next pound harder at £110,000 than at £150,000, and harder still at £20,000 for a family on Universal Credit. The rich, the middle and the poor hear the same message from it: don’t earn more.

Two people, one message

Take two people, one on each side of the argument.

A earns £55,000. They aren’t rich by anyone’s definition, and they are told the tax system is built to be fair to people like them. They have two children and get a £10,000 promotion. They have been paying 42p on the next pound since £50,270, a line frozen since 2021. From £60,000, the Child Benefit charge starts taking back their children’s benefit as well.

B earns £95,000. To many readers that sounds comfortable, and outside London it often is. But B rents in the South East, commutes, and has a toddler in nursery. B is offered a £10,000 bonus. The first £5,000 costs 42p in the pound. The next £5,000 costs 62p. And once B’s adjusted net income passes £100,000, the family loses eligibility for the working-parent funded hours and the childcare top-up, worth thousands.

What you keep of £10,000 more

Of £10,000 more

A: £55,000 to £65,000, two children

B: £95,000 to £105,000, one child in nursery

Tax and National Insurance

£4,200

£5,200

Child Benefit clawed back

£584

Already gone

Childcare support lost

None

Working-parent funded hours and up to £2,000 top-up

You keep

£5,216

£4,800, before the childcare

Side income after £3,000

Taxed at 42%, plus the clawback

Taxed at 62%, plus the cliff

A gets a promotion. Of every £1 of the rise, the state keeps 48p. B gets a bonus. The state keeps 52p, and then the nursery bill arrives in full. For both, the £3,000 side-income allowance changes nothing about the next decision. It relieves the first few pounds of side income. Every pound after that lands on the same staircase.

The £3,000 itself

Even on its own terms, the new allowance has the same habits as the rest of the system. It tests gross takings, not profit, so someone selling things they make, with real material costs, reaches the line long before a consultant with none. And it is all or nothing on who pays you. Take a single trading payment from your own employer, from a partnership you belong to, or from a small company you or your family control, and you lose the allowance altogether, not just on that payment. Go into business with a friend, and it doesn’t apply at all.

So the relief favours one shape of venture: alone, unincorporated, and selling only to strangers. That is not how many businesses start. They start with a colleague, a spouse, a first customer who already knows you. The rules decide which of those beginnings get help.

A 60% rate nobody voted for

The taper was announced in the April 2009 Budget, in a recession. That December the Chancellor said the burden of his tax rises would fall on “those with the broadest shoulders”. That was the stated purpose: to take more from people with higher incomes. Fine. Then legislate a rate. Instead the rate is hidden inside the withdrawal of an allowance, £1 for every £2 earned. Parliament has never been asked to vote for a 60% income tax rate as a rate. Britain has one anyway.

And the line has never moved. £100,000 in 2010 would be about £160,000 today if it had risen with consumer prices, on one estimate. On the same analysis, about 2.06 million people earn above it this year, more than three times the 588,000 when it began. The “broadest shoulders” of 2010 now include people the rule was never aimed at.

Frozen, without a vote on a rise

The personal allowance has been frozen at £12,570 since 2021 and will stay there until 2031, a full decade. The Institute for Fiscal Studies estimates that 4.9 million more people are paying income tax in 2026-27 than would have been if it had risen with prices. The trading allowance itself sat at £1,000 from 2017 to 2027.

A rise in tax rates is debated as a rise. A freeze raises more every year, quietly, without anyone announcing one. That is the most convenient tax a government has, and nobody has to defend it.

One number for every region

The lines are national. The costs are not. In September 2026, the Office for National Statistics put average monthly private rent at £2,338 in London, against £790 in the North East and £848 in Wales. A household on £100,000 in the South East and one on £100,000 in Sunderland are not equally rich. The tax system treats them as if they were.

Everyday prices differ less than housing does: when the ONS last compared regional price levels, it found London about 7% above the UK average. The gap that matters is the roof over your head, and that is exactly the cost a national line ignores.

It cuts both ways. The same national lines treat £25,000 in London as if it went as far as £25,000 in Wales. A single number set in Westminster cannot know what a pound buys in each of a thousand towns. It doesn’t try.

Earn it and you can’t use it; save it and they’ll tax it later

The rules leave you three things to do with the next pound. Take it, and lose most of it, or your childcare. Turn it away. Or lock it in a pension you can’t touch for decades. None of them buys a bigger home, a second child or savings you can use.

Then even that route is narrowed. From April 2027, most pension money left unused at death will count towards inheritance tax. People who did exactly what the rules rewarded may see what they set aside for their children taxed on the way out.

This is not a theory. When pension tax rules made extra work cost senior doctors more than it paid, they stopped doing it. In 2019 the doctors’ union reported that 42% of GPs and 30% of consultants had already cut their workload. The Government accepted the problem: in 2023 it raised the annual pension allowance and removed the lifetime allowance charge, abolishing the limit itself the following year. Even so, in 2025 one consultant in five said they had cut regular overtime because of the pension taper. People with skills the country needs, turning down paid work because of the tax on the next pound.

One fix, then another

Ludwig von Mises explained how this happens. A government intervenes; the intervention produces results it did not want; so it intervenes again to fix those, and again. That is the history here. A taper to tax high earners. A childcare scheme that needed a cut-off. A pension route that people used to escape the taper, and that the Treasury came to see as a way to pass on wealth. Now a tax on the pension at death. Each step lands on the last, and every one of them falls on the next pound someone might have earned.

The new £3,000 allowance belongs to the same family. It is a fix for one corner of the problem, side income too small to be worth the paperwork, bolted onto a system whose real problem is everywhere else. It helps the first pounds. It leaves the next ones exactly where they were.

“High earners should pay more”

That’s the best objection, and on its own terms it is consistent: tax by ability to pay. But this system doesn’t do that. A worker on £110,000 pays more on the next pound than one on £150,000. A family on Universal Credit keeps less of the next pound than either. The objection describes a system that rises smoothly with income. Britain doesn’t have one.

What the alternative looks like

The Austrian answer is not a cleverer taper. It is fewer lines. One tax-free amount for everyone, the same however the money is earned, whether salary, bonus or side business. No withdrawal of allowances as income rises, and no benefit or childcare support that vanishes at a single pound. Every line that remains moves with prices automatically, so nobody drifts into a higher rate without earning more in real terms.

That is not a giveaway to anyone. It is the end of a system in which a Treasury official must guess, for millions of households in thousands of towns, how much extra work is worth their while. Let people answer that themselves. They know their costs, their children and their plans. The tax system doesn’t, and can’t.

Good intentions don’t change the arithmetic

Each of these rules was defended on its own. Added up, they tell people at almost every income not to earn the next pound, and they take most of it from those who do. Whatever its ministers say, Britain’s rules tell people not to become more productive or wealthier. An economy grows at the margin, in the extra shift, the bonus taken, the business started on a Saturday. That is exactly where these rules bite hardest.

REAL-WORLD BUSINESS IMPACT

❝

If you have side income

—       Measure gross takings, not profit. The £3,000 test counts what comes in. From April 2027, takings up to £3,000 are tax-free and needn’t be reported; above it, you choose between deducting your costs or the £3,000.

—       Check who pays you. A single trading payment from your own employer, your partnership or a small company you or your family control can cancel the allowance altogether.

❝

If you pay bonuses

—       Expect staff near £100,000 to refuse cash. Many will ask for pension contributions instead. That is the rules working as written.

❝

If you’re a parent near £100,000

—       The test is adjusted net income. Pension contributions reduce it. Check your position before you accept a bonus or a rise.

YOUR ACTIONABLE TAKEAWAY

This is analysis, not tax advice. Check your own position with an adviser.

❝

01 · Work out your rate on the next pound, not your average rate. It decides whether extra work pays.

❝

02 · For 2026-27, the trading allowance is still £1,000. The £3,000 starts on 6 April 2027.

❝

03 · If you’re near £100,000, check your adjusted net income before the tax year ends. The childcare cut-off has no taper.

❝

04 · If you plan to leave pensions to your family, take advice before April 2027, when unused funds come into inheritance tax.

❝

05 · Watch the Finance Bill until it becomes law. Clause 23 sets the £3,000 from 2027-28; Parliament can still amend it.

THE FREE-MARKET ALTERNATIVE

One tax-free amount for every person, the same for every pound however it is earned, with no tapers, no cliffs and every line moving with prices automatically.

That protects the parent who takes the bonus, the doctor who takes the extra shift, the worker on benefits who takes the extra hours, and the person who starts something on a Saturday.

It restores a simple rule: the next pound you earn is never taxed harder than the last.

OVER TO YOU
Have the rules ever made you turn down a bonus, a shift or a side business? Reply and tell me what you gave up.

Stay free,

Jean-Pierre

The Austrian Actor

P.S. New here? Every past issue is in the archive at theaustrianactor.com.

Before you go: if this made a policy clearer, forward it to one person it affects. When they subscribe with your link, you get our Policy Impact Checklist, and five referrals earn you a short private explanation of any policy you choose.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate