
The Austrian Actor
WHERE AUSTRIAN ECONOMICS MEETS REAL WORLD ACTION
ISSUE #25
FLAGSHIP EDITION
Scotland’s draft Bill lets Ministers cap what large grocers charge for essential food. Its own impact assessment shows where the cost would go instead.
It’s November in Dundee. A mother of two picks up six free-range eggs at the big supermarket: £1.80. Eggs have risen 59.8% since 2020, faster than food in general, and she feels every penny of it.
Up the coast in Aberdeenshire, an egg farmer is deciding whether to restock the sheds that bird flu emptied. New hens, feed and heating all cost money up front. She’ll restock if eggs will pay for it.
They’re both reading the same number. To the mother, £1.80 says eggs are dear. To the farmer, it says more eggs are wanted.
The Scottish Government wants the power to change that number. It can’t change what the number is saying.
POLICY SPOTLIGHT
On 1 September the Scottish Government published a consultation on price caps for essential food, with a draft Food Price Cap (Scotland) Bill attached. Responses close on 24 November. The Bill hasn’t been introduced to Parliament, so its wording can still change.
Under the draft, a large grocer that sells a food Ministers have specified must offer at least one product of that food at or below a price Ministers set. The duty applies at every store and online, at all times. A grocer is covered only if, at the end of its last financial year, it had more than 250 employees, more than £250 million of turnover, and more than half of that turnover from groceries. Takeaways are exempt.
Almost everything else is left to Ministers, by regulation:
What the draft Bill leaves to Ministers
Decision | Who decides | Draft Bill |
|---|---|---|
Which foods are capped | Ministers, by regulation | section 4 |
The cap and how it’s calculated | Ministers, by regulation | section 6 |
Who is covered | Ministers may change the test | section 5(4) |
When the cap is suspended or revived | Ministers, by regulation | section 7 |
Changes to other laws, including this one | Ministers, by regulation | section 18(2) |
The cap itself can be uprated with inflation. The £250 million and 250-employee lines aren’t uprated automatically. There’s no duty to stock a capped food. The law would lapse a year after a review held four to six years in, or eight years after the first caps, whichever comes first, unless Ministers extend it by regulation.
The Government’s case:
— Food has outpaced pay. Citing official statistics, the paper says food prices rose 38.1% from 2020 to July 2026, against 35.3% for average incomes.
— The poorest pay most. The poorest fifth of households spend 15.2% of their income on food and soft drinks, against 10.9% on average.
— Hunger is real. It cites a charity estimate that one million people in Scotland, including 210,000 children, lived in food-insecure households in 2024.
— Shocks will come again. Bird flu, energy costs and war have all hit food prices, and the Government wants a tool ready for the next one.
Concede all of it. The figures are real, the hardship is real, and the papers are unusually candid: they set out the risks, propose a review and a lapse date, and decline to force grocers to stock capped food. Few governments consult this openly on their own doubts.
Take every word of that as true. What follows is unaffected.
THE AUSTRIAN LENS
The price is a message
The consultation describes supermarket prices the way an economist would: they arise from the dealings between shoppers and retailers, “largely owing to supply and demand”. It also cites the Competition and Markets Authority’s finding that food inflation came mainly from rising costs throughout the supply chain, not from weaker competition, and that the grocery market is broadly competitive.
That’s the Government agreeing that the price is telling the truth. Eggs rose because bird flu cut the flocks and feed, energy and wages cost more. The high price is how millions of people learn, without anyone telling them, that eggs are scarce: shoppers use them a little more carefully, and farmers get the signal to restock.
Friedrich Hayek called this the problem a market solves. The knowledge an economy runs on never sits in one place. It exists only as “dispersed bits of incomplete and frequently contradictory knowledge” held by millions of people. A price gathers those bits into a single number anyone can act on. Cap the number, and the message stops arriving.
Three caps, three outcomes
The Government’s own worked example is the one in our cold open: six medium free-range eggs at £1.80. Its impact assessment sets out three ways to cap them. The chart shows what each does.
A price ceiling only bites below the market price, and then it creates a shortage. Illustrative curves; the three prices are the Scottish Government’s.

The Government’s three options for eggs
Cap | What happens | The Government’s own verdict |
|---|---|---|
£1.98, 10% above today | Nothing, unless prices rise past it | No immediate benefit |
£1.80, today’s price | Nothing today | Benefits may be limited |
£1.62, 10% below today | Buyers want more than sellers offer | Could mean selling below cost |
This is the logic of every price ceiling. Above the market price it does nothing. Below it, more people want eggs at £1.62 than anyone will supply at £1.62, and the gap between the two is the shortage. A ceiling below the market price encourages buying and discourages producing at the same time, so it worsens the very scarcity it was meant to relieve. And as the shortage shows, the pressure grows for still more controls.
So the cap helps only when it does harm. A cap that changes nothing achieves nothing. A cap that bites creates a gap between what people want and what is offered, and something has to close it.
Where 10% goes when profit is 3%
The usual hope is that the supermarkets will absorb the cut. The impact assessment explains why they can’t. Citing industry figures given to the Competition and Markets Authority, it says about 70% of a supermarket’s revenue goes on the cost of the goods themselves and 27% on running the business, leaving about 3% profit.
A cap 10% below the market can’t come out of a 3% margin. So the impact assessment lists where it would come from instead:
— Suppliers and farmers, through renegotiated terms, with knock-on effects on quality and the use of local produce;
— Shoppers buying anything else, through higher prices on uncapped goods;
— The shelf, through smaller ranges or capped products withdrawn;
— The future, through a sharp rise in prices when a cap ends.
Its conclusion is blunt: the effect on the cost of an ordinary shopping basket “may be neutral or ambiguous”. And in its annex on economic theory, it adds that price caps may reduce total welfare “by weakening the price signals that help coordinate production and consumption decisions”. That is the Austrian argument, made in the Government’s own document.
Back in Aberdeenshire
Go back to the egg farmer. Suppose a cap 10% below today’s price comes in, and the chains do what the impact assessment expects first: they lean on their suppliers. The packer pays her less. The price that was telling her to restock now tells her the opposite.
So the sheds bird flu emptied stay empty a little longer, and next year there are fewer Scottish eggs, not more. The impact assessment itself warns that suppliers may turn to cheaper imports, some produced to lower welfare standards. A cap meant to make eggs affordable can leave the country with fewer of its own.
The shelf that quietly empties
Scotland’s version is gentler than the textbook case, and that matters. The cap would bind one line per food, at the big chains only, and there’s no duty to stock it. The consultation itself concedes that retailers “may simply” choose not to stock a capped item.
So the shortage is unlikely to look like empty shelves and queues. More likely, it looks like the cheapest line quietly disappearing, the capped eggs moved to a smaller pack size or a less convenient store, and a few pence added to the bread, cheese and coffee beside them. Each change is small and easy to miss. That’s why the cost of a price cap is so easy to deny.
Knowledge nobody has
To set a cap that bites without breaking supply, Ministers would need to know each food’s costs at every stage from farm to shelf. The impact assessment admits the problem: with so many intermediaries, it says, no one in the supply chain is likely to see all the costs and prices paid, even for a single-ingredient product. The Government says it can’t yet put numbers on the costs, and that doing so may prove too complex.
Yet the draft Bill would let Ministers set the price for every covered store in Scotland, with regard to a list of factors that ends, in section 8, with “such other matters as the Scottish Ministers consider appropriate”. The price system already does that sum, every day, using knowledge no Minister has. The cap replaces it with a guess.
One line, two shops
The coverage test is all or nothing, and it’s applied to the whole business, not the store. A chain’s small city-centre store would be covered. The independent shop next door, with a bigger floor, would not. The impact assessment counts 1,490 covered outlets, including 325 in the most deprived fifth of Scotland’s areas.
It also admits the knock-on effect: if capped prices open a wide gap, shoppers could move to the big chains, and the independents and convenience stores that rely on staples could lose trade. A measure meant to help poorer areas could squeeze the shops many people there depend on.
And the lines won’t stay still. The cap can be uprated with inflation, but the £250 million turnover line isn’t uprated automatically. With food prices up 38.1% since 2020, rising prices alone push more grocers over the line each year, unless Ministers move it. The Bill lets them do exactly that, by regulation.
What happened in Hungary
The consultation describes other countries’ caps, including Hungary’s from 2022 to 2023, which also required minimum stock levels, and notes that the EU’s court later found it disproportionate. It doesn’t say what happened to prices.
Hungary’s own central bank records that, from August 2022 to September 2023, Hungary had the highest food inflation in the EU. In December 2022 one of its economists found that retailers had passed the price rises they couldn’t make on capped goods onto other products, wiping out the cap’s effect on measured inflation. His figures show it happening next door to the capped goods: by early December, icing sugar cost 2.2 times its February price while granulated sugar was capped, lard 2.15 times while sunflower oil was capped, and lower-fat milk 1.9 times while standard 2.8% milk was capped. The central bank’s 2024 study concluded that the caps had not helped restrain food inflation, and found that retailers’ overall margin was no lower in 2022 than in 2021: the loss on capped goods was made up on everything else. Hungary also had a falling currency, a drought and new taxes on retailers, and some Hungarian economists dispute how much the caps added. But they didn’t prevent the worst food inflation in the EU, and the cost moved much as Scotland’s impact assessment says it could.
The record shows something else, too. Hungary’s “temporary” cap was extended several times, then replaced with compulsory discounts, then with caps on profit margins. Croatia’s caps, introduced in 2022 to give households immediate relief, have been widened twice and have no end date. Once a government sets food prices, it tends to keep setting them.
“It only guarantees one cheap line”
That’s the strongest objection. The cap binds only one product per food, budget lines already exist, and some discounters already sell six free-range eggs below the big chains’ price. So, the argument goes, the cap merely guarantees a cheap option everywhere, at little cost.
But that cuts both ways. If the cap sits at or above what grocers already charge, it changes nothing for the mother in Dundee, as the Government concedes for eggs. If it sits below, every consequence above follows. The objection describes a cap set where it does no harm, and therefore no good. What it would really create is the power: Ministers able to choose the foods, set the prices and widen the scope, by regulation, whenever the next shock comes.
A cap doesn’t cut the cost. It chooses who pays it.
Every part of the Government’s own analysis points the same way. The cost of producing eggs doesn’t change when a Minister writes a lower number. It falls on someone: the farmer, the shopper buying uncapped food, the independent shop, or the shopper who finds the capped line gone. A price cap doesn’t cut the cost of food. It chooses who pays it.
So if the aim is cheaper food for the poorest households, there’s a simple test of any measure: does it add supply, or only move the cost? A cap moves it.
REAL-WORLD BUSINESS IMPACT
If you run a grocery business near the lines
— Check all three tests for your last financial year. Over 250 employees, over £250 million turnover and over half from groceries, counted across the whole business, UK-wide in the impact assessment’s figures. Fail one test and the duty doesn’t apply.
— Expect the lines to move. Ministers could change the test by regulation, and food inflation alone pushes turnover up.
If you supply the big chains
— The impact assessment expects pressure on your terms. Renegotiation with suppliers is the first response it lists. Review price-adjustment clauses and how your contracts handle a capped product.
If you run an independent shop
— You wouldn’t be capped, but you could lose trade. The impact assessment warns shoppers may move to the capped chains for staples. Watch which foods are specified.
YOUR ACTIONABLE TAKEAWAY
This is analysis, not legal advice. Check your own position with an adviser.
01 · Respond to the consultation by 24 November. The Government says it can’t yet quantify costs. Your margins, supply terms and range decisions are the evidence it’s asking for.
02 · Run your numbers against a cap 10% below today’s price for your main staples, the Government’s own example. Know what you would cut, raise or drop.
03 · If you’re close to the size lines, check them every year end. The test looks back at your last financial year.
04 · Suppliers: read your contracts now for how price changes and range changes are handled.
05 · Watch for the Bill’s introduction. This is a draft. The foods, the caps and the scope would all come later, in regulations.
THE FREE-MARKET ALTERNATIVE
Leave the price of food to the people who grow, sell and buy it, so a high price can do its job of calling out more supply.
That protects the farmer deciding whether to restock, the corner shop competing on its own terms, and the shopper whose uncapped basket would otherwise carry the cost.
It restores one rule for every grocer, large or small: charge what customers will pay, and compete to charge less.
OVER TO YOU
If you supply or run a grocery business in Scotland, how would a cap below today’s price change what you stock or charge? Reply and tell me.
Stay free,
Jean-Pierre
The Austrian Actor
P.S. New here? Every past issue is in the archive at theaustrianactor.com.
Before you go: if this made a policy clearer, forward it to one person it affects. When they subscribe with your link, you get our Policy Impact Checklist, and five referrals earn you a short private explanation of any policy you choose.
