
The Austrian Actor
WHERE AUSTRIAN ECONOMICS MEETS REAL WORLD ACTION
ISSUE #29
STANDARD EDITION
From April 2027 a café pays no business rates and the vape shop next door pays £5,364. Same street, same size. The difference: a minister's opinion.
Two units stand side by side on an English high street. Same size, same landlord, same rateable value: £12,000. One is a café. The other is a vape shop. Today neither pays a penny in business rates, because both get full small business relief.
From 1 April 2027 the café still pays nothing. The vape shop next door pays about £5,364 a year.
Nothing about the units changes. Nothing about the street changes. The only difference is a minister's view of what is sold inside.
POLICY SPOTLIGHT
At the Budget on 28 October the government raised the Small Business Rate Relief thresholds for “qualifying” retail, hospitality and leisure properties in England. From April 2027 they get full relief up to a rateable value of £18,000, up from £12,000, tapering to nothing at £21,000, up from £15,000. Every other small business stays on the old £12,000 and £15,000 lines. Vape shops lose small business relief altogether, and lose the lower retail multiplier. Adult gaming centres keep only the old lines.
Gross rates bills, 2026/27 and 2027/28
Unit (rateable value) | 2026/27 | 2027/28 |
|---|---|---|
Café (£12,000) | nil | nil |
Vape shop (£12,000) | nil | £5,364 |
Café (£17,000) | £6,494 | nil |
Accountant's office (£17,000) | £7,344 | £7,599 |
Bills are gross, before transitional relief, the cap on retail bills, or the 1p supplement, which, where it applies, would add about £120 at £12,000. The examples use values on the list that took effect at the April 2026 revaluation; some 2026/27 bills are held down by transitional relief. The exact taper between £18,000 and £21,000 will be set in regulations promised “in the coming weeks”. The new thresholds are fixed in cash “until 31/3/29”.
Concede what is fair. This is a real tax cut. The government says a further 70,000 retail, hospitality and leisure businesses will pay no rates at all, including 3,500 pubs, 3,900 restaurants, 2,200 cafés and 1,700 hairdressers and beauty salons. It costs about £315 million in its first year. Pubs get extra relief on top, up to 35%. High streets have had a hard decade.
Take every word of that as true. What follows is unaffected.
THE AUSTRIAN LENS
A tax cut, handed out by trade
Start with what is right. Cutting business rates is good. Every pound a café keeps is a pound for staff, stock or a better fit-out. Had the government cut rates for every business, there would be nothing to object to.
That is not what it did. The relief goes to trades on a list that ministers draw and redraw. Banks and professional services were never on it. Vape shops are now struck off. The official letter explaining the change lists, among its measures, the “removal of business rates relief for businesses that do not make a positive contribution to communities”. The Budget says the reliefs will be “better targeted at businesses that support thriving high streets”.
It is paid for partly by a rival. From October 2027 online marketplaces must collect VAT for UK sellers with over £90,000 of sales through them. The government says this tackles sellers who don't pay what they owe, and it may. But the money is not handed back to everyone who pays rates. It is “reinvested into the high street through reductions to business rates”, to protect “the high street from unfair competition”. A relief given by trade, and paid for by a competing trade, is a subsidy, whatever it is called.
A vote is not a purchase
Who decides what makes a high street thrive? A high street is the sum of millions of small choices: where to buy a coffee, where to get a haircut, where to buy a vape. Each is made by one person, with their own money, and each shows up in the takings of the shop that won it.
No election, however large the majority, tells a minister which shop each customer wants. A vote picks a government once every few years, on a whole package. Customers choose shops every day, one purchase at a time. When the state ranks trades by their “positive contribution to communities”, it replaces all those judgments with one: a view of what the public, taken as a whole, ought to want.
What you see, and what you don't
What you see is 70,000 small businesses paying no rates. What you don't see is the vape shop that closes, and the empty unit where it stood. Or the café that stays below £18,000 of rateable value, because crossing the next £3,000 would take its bill from nil to £8,295 a year: on average about £2.77 in rates for every £1 of value, and more towards the top. Or the second site never opened, because a second property can cost the first its relief once the grace period ends. Or the online seller, often a small firm itself, whose collected VAT pays for a rival's discount.
Rates bill against rateable value from April 2027: a café, an accountant's office and a vape shop.

None of these lines moves with prices. The old £12,000 and £15,000 thresholds were set in 2017 and never changed. The new ones are fixed again, to 2029.
“But vape shops are bad for society”
That is the objection most readers will reach for, so take it head on. Suppose most people do think vaping is a bad habit. Where does that judgment show up? At the till. A vape shop survives on a high street only because, day after day, enough adults walk in and buy with their own money. The neighbours who disapprove have already cast the vote that counts: they walk past. If everyone truly felt that way, the shop would close without a minister lifting a finger.
So the extra tax is not needed to record society's judgment. It is there to override the judgment of the people who actually shop there. Disapproval is free to persuade, to warn, to promote the alternative. What it may not do, in a free society, is send the bill for one adult's choice to the shop that served them.
Nor does the list measure harm. Pubs, which sell alcohol, get extra relief. The NHS says “Nicotine vaping is less harmful than smoking. It's also one of the most effective tools for quitting smoking.” The Budget raises duty on higher-stakes gaming machines, but keeps the old rate on lower-stake ones “to protect pubs and seaside arcades”. And a rates bill is a tax on floor space. It is the same whether the shelves hold e-liquid or birthday cards. It cannot tell a harmful sale from a harmless one.
What about addiction? Nicotine is addictive, which is exactly why the NHS treats vapes as a way off cigarettes. Vapes are legal. An adult who finds a habit hard to break is still the person entitled to decide whether to keep it. Selling to children, or lying about a product, are real wrongs, and they are wrongs whoever commits them. A higher rates bill does not stop one sale to a child. It just makes the legal shop dearer to run.
And notice what the principle allows. Once the state may tax a shop for the choices of its customers, the list is whatever the minister of the day disapproves of. This year it is vape shops and gaming centres. Nothing in the rule stops the next list from including takeaways, sweet shops, or yours.
The customer was never asked
Relief by trade does not make a high street thrive. Customers do, one purchase at a time. A tax that sorts shops into deserving and undeserving takes that decision away from the people paying, and hands it to people who never set foot inside.
REAL-WORLD BUSINESS IMPACT
If you run a shop, café, pub or salon in England
— Check whether you qualify, and your rateable value. From April 2027 full relief runs to £18,000, tapering to £21,000. Bills are capped by inflation in 2027/28 and 2028/29.
If you plan to expand or take a second site
— Price the whole bill, not just the rent. Between £18,000 and £21,000 the bill climbs from nil to £8,295, on average about £2.77 for each £1 of rateable value. A second property must keep your total within £29,999 to keep relief.
If you run a vape shop or an adult gaming centre
— Budget for the full bill from April 2027. A vape shop at £12,000 goes from nil to about £5,364 gross. The definition of “vape shop” is still to come in guidance.
If you plan improvements
— The cap does not cover them. The inflation cap on retail bills does not apply to rises in rateable value that come from improvements.
YOUR ACTIONABLE TAKEAWAY
This is analysis, not legal or financial advice. Check your own position with an adviser.
01 · Look up your rateable value on GOV.UK and check which list your trade is on.
02 · Model your 2027/28 bill at the right multiplier: 39.5p for qualifying retail and hospitality, 44.7p for other small businesses.
03 · Before taking a second site, check the grace period and the £29,999 total limit with your council.
04 · Watch for the regulations “in the coming weeks”. They will set the taper and define a vape shop.
05 · Near £18,000, price an expansion on the rates as well as the rent. The next £3,000 of value can cost £8,295 a year.
THE FREE-MARKET ALTERNATIVE
Abolish business rates, for every property and every trade alike, with no reliefs, multipliers or thresholds that depend on what a business sells or what a minister thinks of it.
That protects the café that wants to grow, the vape shop that wants to stay open, and the online seller who should not be funding either.
It leaves the judgment of which shops a street needs where it belongs: with the people who shop there.
OVER TO YOU
If you run a business on an English high street, has the rates bill ever decided how big you grew, or whether you opened a second site? Reply and tell me.
Stay free,
Jean-Pierre
The Austrian Actor
P.S. New here? Every past issue is in the archive at theaustrianactor.com.
Before you go: if this made a policy clearer, forward it to one person it affects. When they subscribe with your link, you get our Policy Impact Checklist, and five referrals earn you a short private explanation of any policy you choose.
