
The Austrian Actor
WHERE AUSTRIAN ECONOMICS MEETS REAL WORLD ACTION
ISSUE #23
STANDARD EDITION
Brazil’s MEI ceiling is set to rise to R$110,000 in 2027. Every employee must still be paid exactly the floor, and the state decides how big the business may be.
It’s November, and you run a lunch counter in Recife on your own. You’re registered as an MEI, Brazil’s “individual micro-entrepreneur”. One small monthly payment covers your taxes and pension.
You have one employee, a cook, on the minimum wage. She’s the reason the queue forms at noon. A restaurant down the road has offered her more.
You’d like to match it, and you can’t. An MEI’s employee must be paid exactly the minimum wage or the agreed floor for her trade. Pay her more, and you’re no longer an MEI.
From January the law lets some MEIs hire a second person. Parliament’s own summaries say rural trades only; the ministry says everyone. Either way, the terms are the same: the floor, and not a real more.
So your cook goes to the restaurant, and you train someone new at the floor. Nobody records that decision.
POLICY SPOTLIGHT
Complementary Law 238 of 2026 was signed on 21 October, after the lower house passed it by 461 votes to 4 and the Senate by 78 to 0. It changes the MEI, the regime used by about 17 million of Brazil’s smallest businesses.
The MEI before and after Law 238
What the law sets | Today | Under Law 238 |
|---|---|---|
Revenue ceiling, tested on the year before | R$81,000 | R$110,000 in 2027; R$140,000 from 2028 |
Employees allowed | 1 | 2, from 2027 (scope disputed) |
What each employee may be paid | Exactly the minimum wage or the trade’s floor | Unchanged |
Who gets the second hire is disputed. Parliament’s own summaries describe it as for rural trades. The ministry, and the way the one-employee rule has always been applied, cover every MEI. The implementing rules will settle it. The pay rule applies to every MEI either way.
The rest stays. The owner trades alone, from one premises, with no stake in another company, in an occupation on a government list. Opening a branch or changing the legal form counts as notice of leaving.
The exit rules stay too. Go up to 20% over the ceiling, and you leave from the next 1 January and pay tax on the excess. Go further, and you’re out backdated to 1 January of that year, with the whole year taxed under the ordinary small-business regime. In 2027 that second line sits at R$132,000.
The law also writes off federal MEI debts built up to 13 October 2026. Owners keep the write-off only if they pay on time for the next six months and drop any lawsuit over the debt. Owners who already paid get nothing back.
One condition: the higher ceilings depend on the budget laws for 2027 to 2029 accounting for the revenue given up.
The Government’s case:
— Formalisation and a pension. The law says the MEI exists to bring small businesses into the formal economy and into social security, and has “no eminently economic or fiscal character”.
— Catching up with prices. The ceiling hasn’t moved since January 2018, while prices rose 55.4% to May 2026. The Government says 101,216 MEIs were pushed out in 2025 and 2026, and that this happened “not only because the businesses grew beyond the MEI ceiling, but because the nominal ceiling did not keep up with inflation”.
— Room to grow. A second employee, it says, “favours the expansion of productive capacity”.
Concede the first and third in full, and the second as far as it goes: the ceiling rises by more than a third in 2027. Trading in the open, with one small payment instead of a filing burden, is the part of this regime that works, and this law moves the right way. The rules are published, so any owner can plan around them. You can price a rule.
Take every word of that as true. What follows is unaffected.
THE AUSTRIAN LENS
A raise is a way out
A wage is a price, agreed by two people who could each walk away. The MEI sets it by law instead, from both sides. The minimum wage stops the owner paying less, and the MEI rule stops her paying more. Together they fix every MEI employee’s pay at one number.
In a 2025 ruling, Brazil’s tax authority said commission that lifts an employee’s pay above the floor takes the business out of the regime. Its rules treat bonuses and even tips the same way. Overtime, night work, hazard pay, paid weekly rest and other constitutional rights tied to the hours or conditions of work are excluded.
So decisions that should turn on a worker’s worth turn on the rule:
— the raise not given;
— the experienced hire not made, because she costs more than the floor;
— the good employee who leaves for a firm that can pay what she’s worth.
A regime meant to bring work into the open can bring it in only at the floor. Pay comes from what work produces. No law can make the cook’s lunches worth less to the customers queuing for them. It can only stop her being paid for them.
One owner, one door, one list
The pay rule is one of several limits on size. No partner, so the cousin with savings can’t buy in. No second premises, so a counter that outgrows its site can’t add another. And only occupations on a government list, so a new kind of business, one nobody had thought of, waits for officials to add it.
A ceiling on takings, not on profit
The ceiling counts what comes in, not what’s left after costs. A corner shop reselling drinks and a designer working from home reach R$110,000 at the same takings, though the shop has kept a fraction of what the designer has. Thin margins hit the line first.
The cliff that reaches back
This is the cliff that punishes growth, with a backdated edge. In 2027, billing one real past R$132,000 doesn’t just end the regime. It re-taxes every month already traded. So the sensible owner turns work away in December.
Frozen again
The Government’s own projection puts the 2018 ceiling, adjusted for expected inflation, at R$143,057.50 by the end of 2028. So R$140,000 is already below it in the year it arrives. The new figures are fixed in reais, a currency that keeps losing value. The ceiling falls each year without anyone voting for it.
Who pays for the write-off
The owners who didn’t pay are forgiven. The ones who paid on time, often by going without, get nothing back. The lesson on offer to every MEI is that, next time, paying on time may be optional.
Who decides
Who decides?
Who decides… | Brazil’s MEI | A free market |
|---|---|---|
How big the business grows | A revenue ceiling in law | Its customers |
What staff are paid | The law: exactly the floor | The employer and the worker |
How many staff | The law: one, or two | The work to be done |
Partners and premises | The law: one owner, one door | The owner, with whoever invests |
Which trades qualify | A government list | Anyone who finds a customer |
What is taxed | Takings, by size band | If anything, money made, under one rule for all |
How the limits change | Frozen, then eroded by inflation | There are no limits to erode |
“Without the pay rule, professionals would run a payroll through the MEI”
That’s the best objection: drop the condition and well-paid staff would be hired through the cheap regime. But a regime that exists to bring workers into the formal economy can’t also forbid paying a formal worker more. If disguised employment is the worry, it’s a separate question, for a rule that applies to every business. Capping the cook’s pay doesn’t answer it.
The confession
Seventeen million businesses sit in a special regime because the ordinary one is too costly to enter. The MEI doesn’t fix that; it admits it. Its limits exist to stop businesses escaping the ordinary system through the cheap door. The answer isn’t a bigger door. It’s an ordinary system simple enough that nobody needs one.
REAL-WORLD BUSINESS IMPACT
If you run an MEI
— If your trade qualifies for a second hire, budget it at the floor, and only the floor. Two staff on the 2026 minimum wage cost R$42,146 a year in pay, with the 13th-month salary. That’s about 38% of the 2027 ceiling, before holiday pay and charges. The 2027 minimum wage is set by decree at the end of this year.
— Commission, bonuses and even tips are exits. Pay that lifts an employee above the floor ends your status. Overtime, night work, hazard pay and paid weekly rest don’t count.
— This year’s takings decide next year. The Government says revenue above R$110,000 in 2026 bars re-entry in 2027.
If you work for an MEI
— Your pay is capped by law, not by your boss. While your employer stays in the regime, it can’t pay you above the floor, whatever you’re worth to the business. Higher pay means your employer leaving the regime, or you leaving the job.
If you advise MEIs or sell to them
— Model the backdated exit, not just the ceiling. Above R$132,000 in 2027, the whole year moves to the ordinary regime. A client near the line in the last quarter needs the sum first.
— Thin-margin clients hit the line first. Resellers reach it long before service businesses with the same profit.
YOUR ACTIONABLE TAKEAWAY
This is analysis, not legal or tax advice. Check your own position with an adviser.
01 · Check your 2026 takings against R$110,000 now. Above it, the Government says you can’t re-enter the regime in 2027.
02 · Treat R$132,000 as your real 2027 line. Up to it, the excess is taxed and you leave the next year. Above it, the whole year is re-taxed from 1 January.
03 · Pay your staff the floor, exactly. Commission, bonuses or tips that lift pay above it end your status. If a worker is worth more, price the move to the ordinary regime before you pay it.
04 · Don’t open a branch or take a partner without planning the exit. Either counts as notice of leaving the regime.
05 · Watch the 2027 budget law. The higher ceilings depend on it accounting for the lost revenue. Check it before you plan January.
THE FREE-MARKET ALTERNATIVE
Let every business pay its staff whatever the two of them agree, take any partner, open any door and trade in anything a customer will buy.
That protects the cook who is worth more than the floor, the owner who wants to keep her, and the trader whose thin margins hit a ceiling long before any real profit.
It restores an order in which customers decide how big a business grows, under one set of rules for every business, whatever its size.
OVER TO YOU
If you run a small business in Brazil, has the MEI’s pay rule ever cost you an employee, or stopped you giving a raise? Reply and tell me what happened.
Stay free,
Jean-Pierre
The Austrian Actor
P.S. New here? Every past issue is in the archive at theaustrianactor.com.
Before you go: if this made a policy clearer, forward it to one person it affects. When they subscribe with your link, you get our Policy Impact Checklist, and five referrals earn you a short private explanation of any policy you choose.
